This argument is getting very boring.
If you don't include the PS3 its unfair, if you do include the PS3 its STILL unfair.
Main reason EVERYONE should quit worrying about player totals and watch total software sales.
HDDVD can claim all they want about attach rate, at the end of the day BD outsells HDDVD every week and on every dual format release. The HDDVD camp should accept it and the BD camp should quit worrying about it.
The Nielsen's are enough for me to see whats going on.
Transformers is great example. We all know it did great on HDDVD, but if it would have been on both the BD title would have ruled and the damn total HD sales would have been sooo much more.
I say let em all go neutral and let it work itself out.