B.J.,
I was referring to the info provided here.
LIVE REAL TIME SATELLITE AND SPACE SHUTTLE TRACKING AND PREDICTIONS
I just read what they gives me.
I don't know about all the formulas and stuff, if it is in error, oh well

Well you could blame it on the Air Force too, since it's all using their KEPs. Actually, when you checked, probably only the old keps were available, so anyone would have gotten the same results. The time you mentioned was right about when the new keps came out I think. I'm guessing that the controllers stopped the sat when it got to the box, but the keps thought the sat was still drifting.
But yeah, that page you used is using the old keps too.
I just looked at the Keps they used, which were:
1 36516U 10016A 10161.29834617 -.00000194 00000-0 00000+0 0 498
2 36516 000.0362 127.5720 0001965 178.3881 315.8346 01.01310731 462
and you see that 10161.29834617 in the first line is the same number I mentioned above. I think yesterday was day 161 in year 10, hence the 10161, and today is day 162 in year 10, hence 10162.
The .6 in the new keps means 60% through the day, but I can't remember (I used to know) if that's the day in UTC or Sidereal time.