I upgraded from the HR22 to HR44, there's a world of difference between speed, recording capability and stability. I had a Dish 622 for years and don't see any difference in speed and stability to the HR44, they are both very good receivers. No experience with the Hopper, but from what I hear it records only 3 shows at the time unless you use primetime; I like the idea of recording 5 shows at any time.